The Other Side: Butterflies and the Border Wall

Exploring the natural beauty and diversity of the Rio Grande Valley, Elizabeth Garcia reflects on what we tear down when a wall is built.

Danaus gilippus, Queen butterflies on retama [PHOTO CREDIT: National Butterfly Center]

IF YOU’VE NEVER BEEN TO THE RIO GRANDE VALLEY (RGV), you might think that a region on the Texas border with Mexico would be a desolate place full of tumbleweeds, cacti, and dangerous people. You’d be surprised. In the RGV, you can go to the symphony, visit the largest one-story library in the nation, and buy an $83,000 Maserati. You can also two-step to a country band, pick a fresh grapefruit from a roadside grove, and eat barbacoa tacos made from a cow’s head that’s been roasted in the earth overnight. The RGV is a world of contradictions. It is known for obesity and starvation, for illiteracy and a new medical school, for cotton fields and Space X, for the worst poverty you can imagine and for unimaginable wealth.

Myscelia ethusa, Mexican Bluewing butterfly [PHOTO CREDIT: National Butterfly Center]

Most people know the RGV as the place where a mighty border wall will intimidate undocumented immigrants on the other side. I know it as the place where this wall will cut off American access to an ecological paradise and hinder the migration of hundreds of species of exotic butterflies and birds every year.

Because it is not possible for us to build anything on our true border (the middle of the Rio Grande River), the border wall is tentatively planned to be constructed up to two miles north of the actual border, forfeiting 80% of the lower RGV’s scarce native habitat to the south side of what is essentially a new border.

The green spaces that will be lost include sanctuaries not only for wildlife, but for American families, too.

Though the RGV is home to many city parks and thousands of acres of privately owned ranches, there is little publicly accessible wilderness left. The border wall will block American access to most of the National Butterfly Center, Santa Ana National Wildlife Refuge, and similar areas, preventing thousands of families from reaching outdoor areas that are vital to their physical and mental health. I know because I have depended on these places for my own wellbeing.

A FEW YEARS AGO, I developed a mysterious autoimmune disease. My body had fought an invading virus so aggressively that it began to misidentify its own healthy cells as enemies, attacking my lungs, skin, and joints. Most days, I used all my energy to work for a few hours and then came home and collapsed on the couch where I focused solely on remaining conscious enough to watch my six-year-old daughter sit in front of the TV or play a video game until her dad returned from his office. Even when my husband arrived and urged me to go to bed, I struggled to drag myself up, slowly shower, and will a heavy toothbrush across my teeth. My care team thought Lupus could be possible. While I waited for more test results, my therapist urged me to minimize stress. She told me to look for birds or butterflies. “Wait at a window for one to appear. Be present. Watch.” She prescribed nature and said that time outdoors would be helpful to my daughter and husband, too.

Biblis hyperia, Red Rim butterfly [PHOTO CREDIT: National Butterfly Center]

At first, my family started looking for birds and insects while waiting in traffic. We stopped at a red light where green parakeets perched on telephone poles and wires. We rolled down the windows to hear them squawk. My daughter marveled at how they nuzzled each other like sweethearts. My husband squeezed my hand.

Driving home from school one afternoon, we came across dragonflies and swallows all swarming and swooping through our neighborhood. Initially, it looked like the swallows were eating the dragonflies, but they both chased something else that was invisible to us. An impatient driver honked and forced us to move on before we could discover what was for lunch.

One day, we drove through a bloom of tiny yellow butterflies that sprinkled down from the heavens like living confetti.

Physically, I still suffered from pain and fatigue, but these little observations lifted my spirits. I realized we needed a closer look at nature. Not the nature that you see from your car windows. Not the nature you sample in a city park full of well-groomed trees and grackles that steal popcorn from trashcans. Not even the nature of our small yard where a hummingbird built a nest in our biggest tree. We needed nature we could get lost in.

The National Butterfly Center was the first place we visited on our quest for wellness. The center’s entrance features a rectangular, white brick building and a shimmering reflecting pool. The sharp, straight lines of the building and pool contrast with the center’s acres of curvy, cultivated gardens and zig-zagging, brush-lined trails.

I marveled at how quiet the grounds were. I was used to the endless noise of the city, but at the center, I could hear the breeze rustling through the tall grass and shrubs. It felt like the land sighed. As I grew closer, I saw many orange butterflies stuck to every plant, opening and closing their wings in time. I passed under a shady canopy of trees, and a Mexican Bluewing landed on my shoulder. For a few moments, the butterfly’s wings rose and fell with my own soft breathing. I lost my troubles and found a bit of peace.

Urbanus proteus, Long-tailed skipper [PHOTO CREDIT: National Butterfly Center]

Atlides halesus, Great Purple Hairstreak butterfly [PHOTO CREDIT: National Butterfly Center]

Over our next visits, we learned that the center isn’t just home to butterflies; it also hosts a variety of native and migratory birds. There are birds dark blue like a north wind and bright blue like a Caribbean sea. There are green jays with cerulean heads and lime green bodies. There are fantastic creatures of other colors, too, like Roseate Spoonbills with pink feathers and spoon-shaped beaks.

Perhaps the most famous visitors, though, are the center’s namesake swallowtails, hairstreaks, emperors, skippers, longtails and, of course, monarchs. Thousands of monarchs arrive each October from northern states, floating into the subtropical RGV like orange autumn leaves. They bring the cool with them. They stay awhile and then spirit away to Mexico in time for Dia de los Muertos. After wintering in Mexico, they ride warm winds north, returning to the National Butterfly Center before bringing spring and summer to Kansas, Michigan, and beyond. The National Butterfly Center is an ideal location to witness this migration, so it’s hard to believe our government wants to seize seventy of its one hundred beautiful acres to build an ugly wall.

CONTRARY TO COMMON BELIEF, the wall will not be erected in an empty, dusty space. Its engineers will cut through a critical conservation corridor, demolishing thousands of acres of lush, riparian habitat. In a sense, the United States is being diminished by its own autoimmune disease. Some of our leaders have become so aggressive in fighting “bad hombres” that they are also hurting innocents on American soil. The border wall is supposed to protect our country’s border, but if it is built where it has been proposed, we will lose some of our nation’s most beloved and necessary land.

Exterior Wall of National Butterfly Center [PHOTO CREDIT: National Butterfly Center]

The border wall will destroy privately owned properties like the National Butterfly Center and the ranches and homesteads of many families. It will also prohibit public access to federally owned land like the Santa Ana Wildlife Refuge. Whatever native land is left intact will be trapped behind the wall along with endangered species like the Texas Tortoise, Texas Horned Lizard, and Texas Indigo, which will be unable to climb out. Further, the wall will separate co-dependent plants and animals that rely on one another to fulfill their life cycles, resulting in species decline and death. It will prevent endangered ocelots from reaching a major source of water, the Rio Grande River, and keep them from accessing diverse mates. It will reduce the already scarce habitat that migratory birds and butterflies depend on when they make two-way stops in the RGV. And it will hurt families like mine who need time in nature to improve their physical and mental health.

If the wall is built where it’s proposed, people and animals in the RGV will lose places that nourish them. The wall will allow us to keep our grey interstates, but we will lose our brown river. We will be able to visit our newly-remodeled shopping mall, but be unable to sit beneath our 900-year-old Montezuma Cyprus tree. We will keep our multimillion dollar convention center, but lose La Lomita Mission. We will preserve our gated communities, but be left outside the gate of the “crown jewel” of the National Wildlife System, Santa Ana National Wildlife Refuge.

To thrive, we need all the parts that make us whole. We need balance. We need our treasured green spaces to be kept a part of this one nation, indivisible, for all.

Elizabeth Parker Garcia

Elizabeth Parker Garcia is a doctoral student at the University of Tennessee- Knoxville. Prior to moving to Tennessee, she lived in the Rio Grande Valley of Texas for 17 years. She believes in and promotes nature's power to improve people's physical and mental health.

More Posts

2 Comments

  1. Beautifully written by Elizabeth. Yes, we need to be able to ballence our live with nature. I was out about 20 minutes this morning in bright sunshine, high humidity not a great time to be outside with my MS but I did it anyway to be with Nature. To my delight was spotting a busy hummingbird oin the Trumpet vine, lots of bloom offering nectar for the bird. Once inside, I’m back to my “to do “ list, refreshed and pushed by that busy humming bird. ❤️👀🙉🌺🙏🏻

    Thank

  2. Elizabeth Parker Garcia says:

    Thanks, Mary! What a beautiful scene! I can just picture it… I appreciate you taking time to share.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*